diff --git a/scripts/hyde/autonomous_run_findings.md b/scripts/hyde/autonomous_run_findings.md index 1efa7ab2..0314bff1 100644 --- a/scripts/hyde/autonomous_run_findings.md +++ b/scripts/hyde/autonomous_run_findings.md @@ -1,5 +1,15 @@ # Autonomous corpus run β€” findings for review (2026-06-16) +> ## 🚩 MANUAL REVIEW NEEDED β€” heat-pump fuel code 39 mis-priced (CALCULATOR) +> **Owner action required.** Database heat-pump certs (fuel code 39) are priced +> at the **gas** rate instead of electricity β†’ SAP over-rated by ~14 +> (uprn_10093114053: eng 93 vs lodged 79). Root cause + evidence in Β§"BUGS" below +> and memory `heat-pump-fuel-39-mispriced`. NOT auto-fixable: the correct +> electricity tariff for a database heat pump (standard code 30 vs a heat-pump +> tariff) is a SAP-domain judgement and it touches the Table-12a off-peak split. +> Decide the tariff, then it's a normal TDD fix. Affects every fuel-39 cert. + + Triaged the full remaining worklist (~95 UPRNs): capture β†’ map β†’ engine SAP, flagging |engβˆ’lodged| β‰₯ 8. Most certs map within Β±4 of lodged. @@ -44,12 +54,27 @@ metres β†’ multi-million-mΒ² windows β†’ HTC in the millions β†’ **SAP clamps to `heat-pump-fuel-39-mispriced`. Needs SAP-domain confirmation of the correct electricity tariff (standard 30 vs heat-pump) β†’ not an autonomous fix. -## ⚠ MODERATE eng-vs-lodged gaps (not catastrophic β€” sample, for review) -Direction is mostly engine UNDER lodged on full-SAP (17.0/17.1) certs: -- βˆ’15: uprn_100090108846 (RdSAP-20, off-peak fuel 29), uprn_100061086424 (RdSAP-17.0) -- βˆ’12: uprn_10090343767 (17.0) Β· βˆ’9: uprn_10090341811, 10093386427 Β· +9: uprn_10090342180 -- A spread of βˆ’6β€¦βˆ’8 on 17.0/17.1. Likely a mix of the full-SAPβ†’RdSAP residual and - possibly more heat-pump-fuel cases. Worth a focused pass after the 2 bugs above. +## ⚠ MODERATE gaps β€” now CLASSIFIED into two patterns + +### Pattern A β€” heat-pump fuel-39 / high-COP certs (= bug #2, both directions) +- uprn_10090342180 (fuel 39): +9 (over-rates, classic fuel-39 mispricing) +- uprn_10093388053 (fuel 39): βˆ’7 Β· uprn_100090108846 (fuel 29 HP, COP 3.44): βˆ’15 +- All resolve once the heat-pump fuel pricing is fixed (🚩 review item above). + +### Pattern B β€” 🚩 MVHR heat recovery NOT modelled β€” CALCULATOR gap (NEW, REVIEW) +Full-SAP **gas** certs that UNDER-predict βˆ’6β€¦βˆ’12 ALL carry an **MVHR system index** +(`mechanical_vent_system_index_number` 500352 / 500230 / 500438 …). MVHR recovers +exhaust heat (big SAP boost), but the engine models mechanical ventilation as +**extract heat loss, not heat recovery** (same as the worked-ref note: "decentralised +MEV β†’ EXTRACT_OR_PIV_OUTSIDE, priced as extract loss"). So every MVHR cert is +systematically under-credited. +- uprn_10090343767 (βˆ’12), 10090341811 (βˆ’9), 10093386427 (βˆ’9), 202211170 (βˆ’7), + 10091636116 (βˆ’8), 10093049867 (βˆ’6), 10090034761 (βˆ’6), 10091636031 (βˆ’6). +- Needs the SAP Appendix Q / PCDB MVHR heat-recovery efficiency model β€” a feature, + not a one-line fix. See memory `mvhr-heat-recovery-not-modelled`. + +### Other +- uprn_100061086424 (RdSAP-17.0, fuel 29, βˆ’15): not yet diagnosed (off-peak electric). ## NOT diagnosed individually The ~70 within-Β±4 certs are not listed; they look healthy.