Resolve#1601 and land #1602/#1603 on the merged-#1609 tree, adjudicated
against Khalim's verified ground truth (not pre_sap).
#1601 (upper-floor +0.25 m joist void) — RESOLVED as keep-raw. The
gov-API/Elmhurst mappers add 0.25 m to upper-storey heights because their
lodged height is a clear internal ceiling. Against verified truth RAW beats
+0.25 on all 7 verified dwellings (16 Stillwater raw -0.35 within-band vs
+0.25 -0.75; every verified property is already under truth and +0.25 only
lowers SAP). pashub surveys internal dimensions (202/205 "Measurements
Location: Internal") and its upper-ground height gap is modal 0.00, so the
joist void is not differentially present and a blanket +0.25 is unsafe.
_map_floor_dimensions keeps the raw surveyed height with a RESOLVED note.
#1602 — semi-exposed / exposed floor exposure. The surveyed "Floor type"
"Semi Exposed (unheated)" now sets is_above_partially_heated_space (RdSAP
§5.14 U=0.7) and "Exposed Floor" sets is_exposed_floor (§5.13 Table 20), on
the lowest storey (floor==0) only, mirroring the gov-API/Elmhurst siblings.
New strict-raise _pashub_floor_exposure (ADR-0015).
#1603a — alternative walls. New AlternativeWall survey dataclass +
extract_alternative_walls (the "Alternative Wall"->"Windows" section) +
_map_pashub_alternative_walls -> sap_alternative_wall_1/2. The cascade
deducts each alt-wall area from the part's main opaque wall (no double
count), so a mixed-facade dwelling is billed at each sub-area's own
construction. The alt-wall block lodges "As Built" (capital B) — aliased to
the existing default insulation code.
#1603b — extension floor construction. ExtensionConstruction gains a floor
block (parsed like the main building) and _map_extension_building_part now
threads floor_type/construction/insulation/u_value_known, which the main
path already did and the extension silently dropped.
Cohort: within-0.5 50.2% -> 51.2%, MAE 0.652 -> 0.624, 0 strict-raise
errors across all 205. Verified-truth safe: none of the 7 verified
dwellings have alt walls, and #1602 moves the one it touches (2 Philips
exposed ext floor) by -0.00. pyright 0-new (mapper baseline 39). Goldens
test_full_building_construction + end_to_end EXTENSION_1 updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three silent-drop extraction fixes the gov-API/Elmhurst mappers already apply
but `from_site_notes` uniquely omitted — each let a favorable default reach the
SAP-10.2 calculator and over-rate the dwelling. Same calculator, so the whole
gap was extraction fidelity (gov-API corpus 78.6% within-0.5 vs pashub 23.9%).
#1598 — electric-shower + bath counts: `_map_sap_heating` built `shower_outlets`
but never set `electric_shower_count`/`mixer_shower_count`/`number_baths`, so
the cascade defaulted to 1 gas mixer / 0 electric, billing electric-shower hot
water off the cheap main system. 100/205 fixtures lodge "Electric Shower".
#1599 — floor label: pashub lodges "Ground Floor" (capital F); the calculator's
RdSAP §5(12) suspended-timber floor-infiltration gate is case-sensitive on
"Ground floor", so the 0.2-ACH term was silently dropped. Normalized at the
mapper boundary. 98/205 suspended-timber.
#1600 — water-heating "None": the RdSAP 10 §10.7 "no water heating system"
signal was discarded and HW inherited the gas combi (58 Hackle 67.7 vs
verified 59). Coded to WHC 999 so the existing electric-immersion + Table
28/29 default fires (also folds in #1594: blank cylinder size is no cylinder,
not a phantom one).
Guinness GMCA 205 cohort: within-0.5 23.9% -> 50.2% (103/205), MAE 1.410 ->
0.650. Ratchets tightened to 0.50 / 0.65. Verified vs Khalim's ground truth
(16 Stillwater 78.2 -> 75.7 vs 76). #1601 (upper-floor +0.25 m) held — it
empirically over-corrects this cohort (internal-vs-external dimension question,
under investigation). pyright: 0 new errors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Second sanctioned exception to "ratchets never loosen" — needs @KhalimCK's
call, since the prior note expected to re-tighten here. Exactly one cohort
property is WHC 950 (16 Bingley Close, +5.946 -> +6.818 = the whole +0.0043);
within-0.5 unchanged at 23.9%. Its pre_sap is verified correct but its ~+6
residual is a known extraction bug, and this hybrid gauge cannot adjudicate a
calculator fix (#1592 Problem 2). The gov-API corpus, which gauges the
calculator alone, improves.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Khalim-authorised MAE loosening: coding window orientation exposes the known
SAP-10.2-vs-lodged offset the zeroed solar gains were masking; within-0.5 is
the north-star metric and jumps 20.0% -> 23.9%.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Manually verified in pashub (Khalim, 2026-07-14): deal 499584755922
(9 Council Houses, CW5 8AP) is F33, not the stale D67 — our computed 34.0
was right within a point; deal 499617935574 (Brightholme, 14 North Road)
is the accredited E43, not the preliminary 53. 58 Hackle Street (D58) and
16 Bingley Close (E52) were confirmed correct, so our +7.8/+5.7 deviations
there are extraction bugs to hunt next. Harness MAE 1.684 -> 1.551; ceiling
ratcheted to 1.56.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The extractor now captures "Heating System (Other):" and the mapper resolves
it to the Table 4a code (301, community boilers) + Table 12 community fuel
(51 via the shared _resolve_community_heating_fuel_code), so
is_heat_network_main routes the DLF / standing-charge / 80%-efficiency
branch instead of pricing the dwelling as an ordinary mains-gas boiler
(fixture 507644414148: +14.3 over-rate closes by ~8.6). Harness MAE
1.726 -> 1.684; ceiling ratcheted to 1.70.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
_parse_room_in_roof captures the RdSAP §3.10 block (age range, floor area,
gables with Exposed/Party type, slopes, common walls, flat ceiling as
length x height) on main and extension roof spaces; both part builders now
carry it to sap_room_in_roof (issue #1590 bug 5 — closes the last #1590
subtask). Harness MAE 1.748 (754917 corrects to pashub's own pre-SAP; RIR
surfaces now billed per-surface instead of as insulated loft).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The surveyed "Ventilation type" label never reached
mechanical_ventilation_kind, so ventilation_from_cert silently defaulted every
mechanical system to NATURAL (24d), dropping its ACH heat loss — 76/205
cohort fixtures lodge dMEV/MEV/PIV (issue #1590 bug 4). Mapping mirrors the
gov-API _API_MECHANICAL_VENTILATION_TO_KIND table (PIV-from-loft is
"as natural"). Harness: within-0.5 12.2% -> 18.5%, MAE 2.538 -> 1.730 — the
campaign's largest single move; floors ratcheted to 0.18 / 1.75.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Not connected to electricity meter" -> 1 (zero Appendix M credit), "Connected
to dwellings electricity meter" -> 2; the raw string fell through the credit
gate's non-int branch to True, crediting a separately-metered array (issue
#1590 bug 3, fixture 499516101839 -6.9 SAP). Harness MAE 2.571 -> 2.538;
ceiling ratcheted to 2.55.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Photovoltaic array kWp Known? Yes" lodges a per-system block (kWp, pitch,
orientation, overshading) instead of the percent-roof estimate; the extractor
only read the estimate, so measured PV never reached the mapper and the
Appendix M credit was silently zero (issue #1590 bug 1). Harness MAE
2.632 -> 2.571 (fixture 507639151843's 13.5-SAP under-rate closes to +0.5);
ceiling ratcheted to 2.58.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Insulation At: None" is the assessor recording zero loft insulation, not an
unknown — with thickness left None, u_roof fell through to the age-band
"assumed insulated" default (0.16 W/m²K at band J/K) instead of the Table 16
uninsulated row (2.30), understating roof loss ~14x (issue #1590 bug 2).
Harness MAE 2.701 -> 2.632 (the two ~7-SAP roof over-raters correct exactly);
ceiling ratcheted to 2.64.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two hubspot_deal_data corrections: 499539910905 D58->B82 (confirmed bad row)
and one C73->C75. Rebuilt via scripts/build_pashub_accuracy_fixtures.py
(no --force; PDFs unchanged).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Secondary fuel 'Mains gas'/'Mains Gas'->26 and 'House Coal'->11 (Table 32);
main-heating control resolution becomes group-aware with a Table 4e Group 3
map ('Charging system linked to use of community heating, room thermostat
only' -> 2306, the code the accredited Elmhurst certs lodge for this cohort;
all four linked-to-use codes are calculation-identical). All 205 Guinness
fixtures now compute (was 201/4 xfails); ratchet re-baselined to the
full-coverage aggregate (12.2% within-0.5 floor, MAE ceiling 2.71) with the
two newly-computable outliers documented for verification.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The control gap surfaces as UnmappedSapCode on main and as UnmappedPasHubLabel
once the #1557 control mapper lands (unmapped community-heating control), so the
harness must swallow both; only the closed fuel-specific MissingMainFuelType is
dropped as a fuel-drop tripwire.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Foundation for PRD #1555: runs each PAS Hub site-note PDF through the
extractor -> EpcPropertyData -> Sap10Calculator and gauges the computed
SAP against pashub's own SAP-10.2 `pre_sap` (from hubspot_deal_data).
- test_pashub_sap_accuracy.py: hybrid gate. Per-fixture "must compute"
(xfail on the known in-progress mapper gaps MissingMainFuelType /
UnmappedSapCode / UnmappedPasHubLabel) + aggregate within-0.5 ratchet
floor, mirroring test_sap_accuracy_corpus.py.
- 205 image-stripped site-note PDFs + manifest.json. Images stripped so
the repo footprint stays ~52MB while the text layer the extractor reads
is byte-identical.
- build_pashub_accuracy_fixtures.py: provenance/rebuild from S3 +
hubspot_deal_data.
All 206 currently xfail on the known heating-string mapper gaps; each fix
(#1556-1568) flips its fixtures to computing and ratchets the floor.
Refs #1555#1568
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
