* Electric-immersion DHW: bill at 100%, not the space boiler's efficiency 🟩
A separate electric immersion heater (SAP water-heating code 903) is 100%
efficient (SAP 10.2 Table 4a) and the space-heating boiler provides no water
heating, so Appendix D2.1 Eq D1 (the boiler seasonal-efficiency cascade) must
not apply to it. But `_water_heating_main` resolves DHW to the SPACE main — a
gas/oil boiler keeps its PCDB record — so three water-efficiency branches in
cert_to_inputs billed the immersion-heated cylinder at the boiler's ~87% summer
efficiency (a mongrel: electric fuel price x gas-boiler efficiency):
1. the scalar `water_eff = water_pcdb_main.summer_efficiency_pct / 100`,
2. the SAP §9.4.11 / Table 4c(2) -5pp no-interlock adjustment, and
3. the Eq D1 (winter, summer) seasonal pair from `pcdb_main`.
Gate all three on `not dhw_is_electric_immersion`; the correct immersion path
(`_water_efficiency_with_category_inherit` -> 1.0, Eq D1 off) then applies,
mirroring the Table 3 zero-primary-loss gate already present for WHC 903.
General bug — fires for any WHC-903 dwelling whose space main is a PCDB gas/oil
boiler. It surfaced via the PasHub campaign's #1600 no-water-heating default
(WHC 999 -> 903) on a gas-combi dwelling: 58 Hackle St M11 4WU, SAP 55.30 ->
57.67 (pre_sap 58, verified 59).
Guardrails: the gov-API RdSAP corpus IMPROVES 78.8% -> 78.9% within-0.5, MAE
0.625 -> 0.622 (a handful of corpus certs with a boiler space main + electric
immersion move closer to accredited) — MAE ceiling ratcheted 0.626 -> 0.625.
Regression pinned in test_cert_to_inputs (RED before / GREEN after). pyright
0-new (cert_to_inputs baseline 30).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* PasHub SAP accuracy: thread low-energy lights + draught lobby (from_site_notes) 🟩
Two systematic silent-drops in the PAS Hub `from_site_notes` path, each a field
the gov-API/Elmhurst mappers thread but site-notes dropped, letting a favourable
default reach the SAP-10.2 calculator. Validated against the correct pashub
oracle (property_baseline_performance.effective_sap_score, portfolio 838):
cohort within-0.5 55.1% → 62.6%, MAE 0.599 → 0.521.
- Low-energy lights: when "exact LED/CFL known = No", PAS Hub lodges an aggregate
"Number of fixed low energy lights?" count. Previously dropped (no dataclass
field / extractor key / mapper thread) → calculator saw 0 low-energy bulbs and
applied the pessimistic L5b/L8c no-data default, under-rating SAP. Now threaded
into low_energy_fixed_lighting_bulbs_count, mirroring from_elmhurst_site_notes.
~6% of the cohort; resolves 58 Hackle (−0.43 vs oracle 59 with #1615).
- Draught lobby: _map_sap_ventilation set only the legacy `draught_lobby` field,
never the canonical `has_draught_lobby` §2 (13) gate the cascade reads, so the
surveyed lobby was ignored and infiltration over-stated. Now mirrors Elmhurst.
Two other audited levers were REJECTED against the pashub oracle (they matched
the gov-cert/RdSAP convention but pashub does not apply them): percent_draughtproofed
(cohort 30.8%) and the §A.2.2 assumed secondary heater (19.2%). A heat-network
control-code fix (2306→2303 for 16 Bingley) is HELD pending spec/Elmhurst
adjudication — it contradicts ADR-0053; see the NOTE on _PASHUB_HEAT_NETWORK_CONTROL_TO_SAP10.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* PasHub heat-network control: room-thermostat-only maps to 2308, not 2306 🟩
The Table 4e Group 3 label "charging linked to use of community heating, room
thermostat only" was mapped to 2306 — the linked-to-use *with-TRVs* code
(control type 3, space charging 1.00). The label explicitly excludes TRVs, so
it is control type 2 / space 1.05 = code 2308/2309 (linked-to-use → DHW 1.00).
2306 asserted TRVs the survey doesn't have and over-rated the cohort's sole
heat-network dwelling (16 Bingley Close 56.89 → 54.01 vs pashub oracle 52).
Verified against SAP 10.2 Table 4e as encoded in cert_to_inputs.py
(_CONTROL_TYPE_BY_CODE 2308→2, space-charging 2308→1.05, DHW 2308→1.00) and the
RdSAP control-label vocabulary in MainheatControlAttributes.py. 2303 (the earlier
audit's guess) is rejected: it is a flat-rate code (DHW 1.05) whose oracle match
was a coincidence of two offsetting spec violations. The residual +2.0 to oracle
52 is the documented SAP-10.2-engine-vs-lodged offset, not a fuel/flags gap
(those were threaded by the #1590 follow-up) — supersedes the ADR-0053 /
HANDOVER_838 "community fuel/flags" attribution.
16 Bingley is the only heat-network fixture in portfolio 838, so this moves one
fixture strictly toward its oracle. Harness ratcheted: within-0.5 0.51→0.58,
MAE 0.625→0.521 (observed 58.5% / 0.520 with all three 2026-07-15 levers).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* PasHub SAP accuracy: restore 3 dropped §2 infiltration inputs (from_site_notes)
`from_site_notes` uniquely dropped three ventilation inputs that the gov-API
and Elmhurst sibling mappers all set, causing a systematic cohort-wide SAP
under-rate vs the company's own accredited SAP-10.2 certs
(property_baseline_performance.effective_sap_score, portfolio 838):
1. percent_draughtproofed — never set, so §2(15) window infiltration was
pinned at its 0.25-ACH worst case on every dwelling. Reconstructed as the
area-weighted % of draught-proofed windows (mirrors Elmhurst
`draught_proofing_percent`). Dominant term.
2. Upper-storey +0.25 m joist void — omitted; now added, matching
`_UPPER_FLOOR_HEIGHT_ADD_M` on the gov-API/Elmhurst paths. This
RE-ADJUDICATES #1601 ("keep raw"): that call was confounded by the
then-present draught-proofing drop suppressing every verified dwelling.
3. sheltered_sides — left None → calculator's flat default of 2, which
over-shelters end/semi/detached (RdSAP §S5 = 1/1/0). Now derived from
built form.
The three are NON-ADDITIVE — each overshoots alone (which is why all three
were previously rejected individually) — but together they land all 7
verified ground-truth dwellings toward truth (none regress) and every built
form near zero. Cohort 62.1% -> 83.3% within-0.5, MAE 0.507 -> 0.377.
Guardrails: gov-API RdSAP corpus unchanged (78.9%, these are from_site_notes-
only helpers). pashub harness 58.5% -> 79.5% / MAE 0.520 -> 0.389; ratchets
tightened 0.58->0.78 and 0.521->0.40. pyright zero-new (mapper baseline 39).
New focused tests in TestFromSiteNotesInfiltrationFixes cover all three
fields incl. area-weighting and the built-form shelter map; goldens updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Resolve#1601 and land #1602/#1603 on the merged-#1609 tree, adjudicated
against Khalim's verified ground truth (not pre_sap).
#1601 (upper-floor +0.25 m joist void) — RESOLVED as keep-raw. The
gov-API/Elmhurst mappers add 0.25 m to upper-storey heights because their
lodged height is a clear internal ceiling. Against verified truth RAW beats
+0.25 on all 7 verified dwellings (16 Stillwater raw -0.35 within-band vs
+0.25 -0.75; every verified property is already under truth and +0.25 only
lowers SAP). pashub surveys internal dimensions (202/205 "Measurements
Location: Internal") and its upper-ground height gap is modal 0.00, so the
joist void is not differentially present and a blanket +0.25 is unsafe.
_map_floor_dimensions keeps the raw surveyed height with a RESOLVED note.
#1602 — semi-exposed / exposed floor exposure. The surveyed "Floor type"
"Semi Exposed (unheated)" now sets is_above_partially_heated_space (RdSAP
§5.14 U=0.7) and "Exposed Floor" sets is_exposed_floor (§5.13 Table 20), on
the lowest storey (floor==0) only, mirroring the gov-API/Elmhurst siblings.
New strict-raise _pashub_floor_exposure (ADR-0015).
#1603a — alternative walls. New AlternativeWall survey dataclass +
extract_alternative_walls (the "Alternative Wall"->"Windows" section) +
_map_pashub_alternative_walls -> sap_alternative_wall_1/2. The cascade
deducts each alt-wall area from the part's main opaque wall (no double
count), so a mixed-facade dwelling is billed at each sub-area's own
construction. The alt-wall block lodges "As Built" (capital B) — aliased to
the existing default insulation code.
#1603b — extension floor construction. ExtensionConstruction gains a floor
block (parsed like the main building) and _map_extension_building_part now
threads floor_type/construction/insulation/u_value_known, which the main
path already did and the extension silently dropped.
Cohort: within-0.5 50.2% -> 51.2%, MAE 0.652 -> 0.624, 0 strict-raise
errors across all 205. Verified-truth safe: none of the 7 verified
dwellings have alt walls, and #1602 moves the one it touches (2 Philips
exposed ext floor) by -0.00. pyright 0-new (mapper baseline 39). Goldens
test_full_building_construction + end_to_end EXTENSION_1 updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Three silent-drop extraction fixes the gov-API/Elmhurst mappers already apply
but `from_site_notes` uniquely omitted — each let a favorable default reach the
SAP-10.2 calculator and over-rate the dwelling. Same calculator, so the whole
gap was extraction fidelity (gov-API corpus 78.6% within-0.5 vs pashub 23.9%).
#1598 — electric-shower + bath counts: `_map_sap_heating` built `shower_outlets`
but never set `electric_shower_count`/`mixer_shower_count`/`number_baths`, so
the cascade defaulted to 1 gas mixer / 0 electric, billing electric-shower hot
water off the cheap main system. 100/205 fixtures lodge "Electric Shower".
#1599 — floor label: pashub lodges "Ground Floor" (capital F); the calculator's
RdSAP §5(12) suspended-timber floor-infiltration gate is case-sensitive on
"Ground floor", so the 0.2-ACH term was silently dropped. Normalized at the
mapper boundary. 98/205 suspended-timber.
#1600 — water-heating "None": the RdSAP 10 §10.7 "no water heating system"
signal was discarded and HW inherited the gas combi (58 Hackle 67.7 vs
verified 59). Coded to WHC 999 so the existing electric-immersion + Table
28/29 default fires (also folds in #1594: blank cylinder size is no cylinder,
not a phantom one).
Guinness GMCA 205 cohort: within-0.5 23.9% -> 50.2% (103/205), MAE 1.410 ->
0.650. Ratchets tightened to 0.50 / 0.65. Verified vs Khalim's ground truth
(16 Stillwater 78.2 -> 75.7 vs 76). #1601 (upper-floor +0.25 m) held — it
empirically over-corrects this cohort (internal-vs-external dimension question,
under investigation). pyright: 0 new errors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The extractor now captures "Heating System (Other):" and the mapper resolves
it to the Table 4a code (301, community boilers) + Table 12 community fuel
(51 via the shared _resolve_community_heating_fuel_code), so
is_heat_network_main routes the DLF / standing-charge / 80%-efficiency
branch instead of pricing the dwelling as an ordinary mains-gas boiler
(fixture 507644414148: +14.3 over-rate closes by ~8.6). Harness MAE
1.726 -> 1.684; ceiling ratcheted to 1.70.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two dig-confirmed defects in the fresh RIR mapping (499617935574 overshot
-9): the roof-space-level insulation (Joists/200mm) was never threaded into
the RIR surfaces, so slopes/commons/flat ceilings fell to the Table 18
"unknown" full-uninsulated 2.30 default; and common walls were mislabeled
"common_wall" (a Simplified-Type-2-only concept) instead of the Detailed-mode
stud_wall every worksheet-validated fixture uses. 44.0 -> ~50.3 on the target
fixture; harness MAE 1.748 -> 1.726.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
_parse_room_in_roof captures the RdSAP §3.10 block (age range, floor area,
gables with Exposed/Party type, slopes, common walls, flat ceiling as
length x height) on main and extension roof spaces; both part builders now
carry it to sap_room_in_roof (issue #1590 bug 5 — closes the last #1590
subtask). Harness MAE 1.748 (754917 corrects to pashub's own pre-SAP; RIR
surfaces now billed per-surface instead of as insulated loft).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
_pashub_room_in_roof mirrors _api_build_room_in_roof: every surveyed RIR
surface (gable typed Exposed/Party per Table 4, slopes, common walls, flat
ceiling) becomes a detailed_surfaces entry of length x height, so the
cascade bills exact RIR surfaces instead of treating the shell as
well-insulated loft (issue #1590 bug 5).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
PasHub surveys never lodge a basement wall, but "System Build (i.e Any
Other)" maps to wall code 6 — the gov-API basement sentinel — and with
wall_is_basement left None the dwelling silently routed through the basement
wall/floor U-value cascade (issue #1590 bug 7). Both part builders now pin
the flag False. Harness MAE 1.732 -> 1.727.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Normal (90-130 litres)"->2, "Large (>170 litres)"->4; "No Access" follows
RdSAP 10 Table 28 p.55 (otherwise-branch 110L for a main-fed cylinder;
electric-immersion No Access strict-raises until meter context is plumbed).
The raw band string was int-or-noned by _cylinder_volume_l_from_code, skipping
the Table 28 volume convention (issue #1590 bug 6). Golden block updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The surveyed "Ventilation type" label never reached
mechanical_ventilation_kind, so ventilation_from_cert silently defaulted every
mechanical system to NATURAL (24d), dropping its ACH heat loss — 76/205
cohort fixtures lodge dMEV/MEV/PIV (issue #1590 bug 4). Mapping mirrors the
gov-API _API_MECHANICAL_VENTILATION_TO_KIND table (PIV-from-loft is
"as natural"). Harness: within-0.5 12.2% -> 18.5%, MAE 2.538 -> 1.730 — the
campaign's largest single move; floors ratcheted to 0.18 / 1.75.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Not connected to electricity meter" -> 1 (zero Appendix M credit), "Connected
to dwellings electricity meter" -> 2; the raw string fell through the credit
gate's non-int branch to True, crediting a separately-metered array (issue
#1590 bug 3, fixture 499516101839 -6.9 SAP). Harness MAE 2.571 -> 2.538;
ceiling ratcheted to 2.55.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
_pashub_pv_arrays mirrors _elmhurst_pv_arrays, reusing its format-agnostic
pitch/orientation/overshading converters (PasHub lodges "South East"
space-separated; normalise to the octant map's hyphenated keys). Wired into
the SapEnergySource construction so the calculator's Appendix M generation
path sees measured PV instead of silently zero credit (issue #1590 bug 1).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
"Insulation At: None" is the assessor recording zero loft insulation, not an
unknown — with thickness left None, u_roof fell through to the age-band
"assumed insulated" default (0.16 W/m²K at band J/K) instead of the Table 16
uninsulated row (2.30), understating roof loss ~14x (issue #1590 bug 2).
Harness MAE 2.701 -> 2.632 (the two ~7-SAP roof over-raters correct exactly);
ceiling ratcheted to 2.64.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Secondary fuel 'Mains gas'/'Mains Gas'->26 and 'House Coal'->11 (Table 32);
main-heating control resolution becomes group-aware with a Table 4e Group 3
map ('Charging system linked to use of community heating, room thermostat
only' -> 2306, the code the accredited Elmhurst certs lodge for this cohort;
all four linked-to-use codes are calculation-identical). All 205 Guinness
fixtures now compute (was 201/4 xfails); ratchet re-baselined to the
full-coverage aggregate (12.2% within-0.5 floor, MAE ceiling 2.71) with the
two newly-computable outliers documented for verification.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Table 4e is organised by heating-system family and the same control label
recurs across groups under different 2xxx codes, so the boiler (Group 1) map is
gated behind a boiler system_type; any other system strict-raises rather than
silently taking a boiler code. Adds a guard that every mapped code exists in the
calculator's _CONTROL_TYPE_BY_CODE inventory.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
roof_construction_type was left None in from_site_notes, so the
calculator's "flat"/"sloping ceiling" substring routing in
heat_transmission couldn't detect flat roofs and every roof (flat or
pitched) fell through the pitched default. country_code was never set
on this path either, so the England/Wales/Scotland/NI U-value cascade
(u_floor, u_basement_floor, u_door) had no country to key off.
Sets roof_construction_type from the surveyed roof_space construction_type
(main building + extensions), and country_code="ENG" for this all-English
cohort, matching the existing from_elmhurst_site_notes path.
Fixes#1566
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`_map_sap_heating` left `main_heating_index_number` None, so the
calculator fell to a generic Table-4b seasonal efficiency instead of the
actual appliance. The site note lodges the boiler by its PCDB `product_id`
(and `summer_efficiency` is always 0), and those ids resolve directly in
the calculator's PCDB (`gas_oil_boiler_record`) — so carrying `product_id`
onto `main_heating_index_number` gives the real SEDBUK efficiency.
Gated on `product_id > 0` (0 = no product lodged → stays None; the
calculator keeps its default). `main_heating_category`/`sap_main_heating_code`
were evaluated and add nothing measurable — the PCDB index alone is the
efficiency source.
Guinness GMCA cohort: within-0.5 12.9% -> 13.4%, MAE 2.657 -> 2.621, no
regression (harness still 206-xfail, no new hard failures).
Closes#1563
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
secondary_fuel_type was hardcoded None in the from_site_notes mapper,
dropping the fuel for the ~67 Guinness GMCA 205 properties that lodge a
"Panel, convector or radiant heaters" secondary heater. Adds
_pashub_secondary_fuel_code (ADR-0015 pattern, mirrors
_pashub_main_fuel_code) mapping "Electricity" -> SAP10 code 30, with
"No Secondary Heating"/blank -> None and unknown labels strict-raising
UnmappedPasHubLabel.
Fixes#1564
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
